Sunday, October 14, 2012

WeeRide Co-Pilot Bike Trailer: don't waste your money!

We did family bike rides with both kids in the trailer until our oldest was about 5, at which point she was simply getting too tall to fit inside (she's taller than average). At that point, we knew it was time for her to graduate to something else, so we looked at our options in "tandem trailers", i.e. trailers where the child pedals. One of the most well known products for taking a child along on a ride is the Adams Trail-a-Bike. They seem to have a good reputation, but they are also one of the more expensive options (suggested retail is over $200, but it looks like Amazon has it for $160).

At the time, we decided it was important to be able to fit it into the trunk of our car. Most newer tandem trailers have some kind of folding feature which makes this possible, but I passed on a chance to by an older Trail-a-Bike because it lacked this feature. In the end, we chose the WeeRide Co-Pilot, which typically sells for less than half the price of the Trail-a-Bike.


Here is a closeup of the hinge in the middle that allows it to be folded over for transportation.


The rear 90% of the bike is solidly built and I have no complaints about it, especially for the price. The part that has turned out to be huge problem is the front part. Here is a closeup.


The hitch mechanism attaches to the seat post of the adult bike. It's not a particularly elegant design, but it works. Behind the hitch are two joints, designed to allow the trailer to move both horizontally and vertically with respect to the bike. The first problem with the joints is that the weld connecting them to the rest of the trailer is not straight. When the hitch is held perfectly level, the trailer bike leans a couple of degrees to one side.


This is not a one-time anomaly. While this trailer has generally received positive reviews on Amazon, there are a number of 1-star reviewers (full disclosure: I am one of them) who have described this same problem. I don't know how common this is, but there are clearly some quality control problems.

The second problem with the joints is that the bushings get looser over time. After 4 summers of regular 10-20 mile bike rides, there is now enough play in the joints that the trailer can flop back and forth several degrees. This is particularly challenging for the adult rider trying to keep the whole rig upright. A few weeks ago this finally resulted in a crash, and we have decided that it's time to retire the Co-Pilot and find a better solution for family cycling. WeeRide's web site says they now have a new hitch design, so it's possible they are aware of this problem.

The lesson learned from all of this was that if you want to buy a tandem trailer, you really need to spend the money on one of the more expensive models. A year after buying the Co-Pilot, I acquired a true tandem, and we have been using both for the last two years. After using both, I've concluded that the only real advantage of a tandem trailer is cost, and that anyone serious enough about riding to make the investment in a tandem is better off skipping the tandem trailer entirely and going straight from a trailer to the back of a tandem. The advantages of this are:

  • Better handling and balancing characteristics than a standard bike pulling a tandem trailer.
  • The child can actually help pedal no matter what gear you're in. Above a certain speed, a child on a one-speed tandem trailer can't pedal fast enough to actually contribute, so they end up just coasting and (in my experience) goofing off in ways that can make it a challenge to keep the bike upright.
  • A tandem can grow with the child past the age where they might be too big for the trailer.

3 comments:

  1. We recently purchased a WeeRide Co Pilot, on the 3rd ride out the rear axle began a banging grinding noise...what to do? Contacted the company, they asked that we video record the problem and send them a clip...

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I would suspect worn out bearings, something which can be tested by seeing how easily the wheel spins on its own. Bearing problems would be unusual on a new bike, but it's possible they were overtightened.

      Delete
  2. We got one of these to have our grand kids ride as they grew. We haven't had any of the issues you mentioned but we haven't done 4 summers worth of regular 10-20 mike bike ride with it either. In our experience this is best suited for the summer weekend afternoon riders. Your advice is spot on if you intend on doing any kind of real mileage on a regular basis. When you get serious about riding your equipment needs to be serious too.

    My wife is a racer, has done over a dozen century rides and does many cross state rides (ragbrai, bam, bak) and a triathlete. I was a bike messenger in NYC and rode most of my life for fun. Unfortunately, I don't ride anymore. But hey, someone has to drive the SAG vehicle and I like A/C.

    ReplyDelete